I'm with you there. I can't like a movie just because a certain actor is in it...PoP was not something I would ever go see, in my opinion, it was made (as the director, I believe) said for teenage boy gamers. I know it was very popular with the Jakettes around the world and that's fine, good for him, they paid him a lot of money and he worked hard for it.
But I can't part with my hard-earned money for a summer blockbuster (think I've mentioned that before). I don't think it even got very good reviews for the genre.
Same with Heath's last movie.
I'm looking forward to LAOD, and I truly hope it's not a Hollywood rehash of other "opposites suddenly attract" with some pathos thrown in.
I never saw The Good Girl, but it was on Fox today, and I was caught by surprise, I had no idea what the story was about or the ending...I thought it was good - not great.
I think it will be a long, long time before we see anything close to the Brokeback phenomenon; the story, director, cast, timing, alignment of the stars...everything was perfect, and it doesn't happen often.
ETA: doesn't happen often: did it ever happen before? I can't think of another movie that has affected me like this one, even though I have many favorites...there's been nothing like Brokeback.